Arctic Ice and Temperatures

Last week I mentioned that Bering Sea ice managed to reach near-normal levels this winter despite relatively warm conditions.  The January-March average ice extent was only slightly below the normal of recent decades, continuing the recovery from the very low ice conditions of (especially) 2017-18 and 2018-19.

The Arctic-wide seasonal sea ice maximum was likewise higher than in most recent years, as documented by Rick Thoman on his blog:

https://alaskaclimate.substack.com/p/march-2024-arctic-sea-ice-update

The relatively abundant ice cover is perhaps consistent with the fact that while tropical and mid-latitude temperatures were extremely elevated in recent months, the Arctic did not see quite the same magnitude of warmth that it did during and after the last big El Niño in 2015-16.  Last time around it seemed that the intense El Niño kicked off a several-year period of really excessive warmth in the Arctic, but so far that hasn't happened with the latest (now dissipating) El Niño.

Here's a simple depiction of mid-latitude versus high-latitude temperature trends in December through February, according to the ERA5 reanalysis:

In the mid-latitude sector from 30-60°N, the winter's average temperature was the second highest on record, behind only 2019-20; but for 60-90°N the winter wasn't quite as warm as the three winters from 2015-16 to 2017-18.

Here's a map comparison of this winter (below, top) with the record warmest winters in the mid-latitude (middle) and high-latitude (bottom) sectors.

Clearly the 2017-18 winter had a very strong Arctic focus of unusual warmth, while it was a colder winter in many mid-latitude locations, at least over the continents.  The Arctic was colder in 2019-20 , but there was extreme warmth across Eurasia as a result of a strongly positive Arctic Oscillation (low pressure over the Arctic, and strong circumpolar flow).

In contrast to both of those years, this winter saw very widespread unusual warmth from the tropics to the Arctic.  Below-normal temperatures at high latitudes were largely confined to certain land areas (Greenland, Scandinavia, parts of Russia, and of course some of Alaska), while air temperatures over the Arctic Ocean were significantly above normal.

Given the very modest reduction in the Arctic's warmth this winter, the recovery in sea ice is interesting and, I think, a little surprising.